![]() ![]() But, I do have some understanding of human nature and will offer merely this.OP, buy the rod you want, do not regret or second guess your desire to own one, do not worry about other's opinions, do not base your desires on others approval or recommendations, you will not be satisfied until you do, it's a commodity, in a worst case scenario if you decide later you do not like it.sell it. My contribution, like others, would be useless in this instance as I do not have experience with Orvis products to any degree of depth. Not completely on track for the thread (my apologies), but not fully off track either.In reading along it was blatantly apparent to me that the OP had already decided to purchase an Orvis rod, it was simply a glass vs carbon quandary seeking opinions of other's preferences. I'm sure either Orvis rod would be fine (as mentioned, the Superfine Carbons have been discontinued but probably can still be purchased if you hunt around, maybe even at a discount), but just wouldn't be my choice.ĮDIT: Not sure exactly what you mean by "travel friendly" (airplane or in the back of a car?), but the SFG is a 3 piece and so the tube presumably is 31-32" whereas the SFC is a 4 piece and thus probably +/- 24." You might also check out the Douglas Upstream rods, they offer a 3 wt in various lengths and configurations-I cast the 7'6" 6 piece at a show a year or two ago and thought it was really nice. I think it lists for around $150 but can often be found for under $120-it definitely casts/fishes above its price point. I'm reluctant to be the one to get this thread off track as you didn't ask for other recommendations and I can't say how it would compare to the rods you asked about (I won't buy Orvis rods and so rarely bother to cast them), but I will say that if "buying blind" you should read up on the Redington Classic Trout 7'6" 3 wt, which is a 4 piece. Is it due to budget? Orvis warranty/reputation? You're just an "Orvis guy"? He's a straight shooter and not giving me the hustle for a higher priced rod.Not to fight the hypo so to speak, but curious as to why you settled on those two rods given that you apparently haven't, and won't be able to, cast them. ![]() The independent dealer has suggested the Superfine. I question the difference a foot makes, but it must have some effect or they wouldn't make them. I have also read where 9 ft is desirable for nymphing and line control in tight quarters. Randy, I agree with the big river/9 ft comment. I'm ready for a store bought stick with a touch more forgiving action.Įstrother, I like your comments on the T3 (costs less too). My timing has to be spot on with this rod. ![]() It is a fast tip action and casts well (so I'm told by several who know). Then in 1990 I built my present rod from a Sage RPLX 5 wt blank. I built a decent rod from a no-name 5 wt graphite blank in 1988, that has a somewhat soft action. My first decent rod was a Fenwick glass from the 70's (just as graphite was coming out). I have an Orvis dealer nearby as well as another full shop that sells Orvis goodies. The bulk of my fishing in Pa would be on 130 ft and less stream widths for stocked trout. You should also review the information on the Orvis website, if cannot visit a store. It really is a question of personal tastes and need both are beautiful, well made in America fly rods. You would give up some delicacy/tippet protection, but you would gain the ability to more easily handle distance, wind and larger fish. ![]() It would offer you the greatest range of use. If you cannot, you might want to consider the 5wt T3 with a mid flex. If possible, you should cast each type in 5wt to see what matches your casting comfort zone best. Two weekends ago, I caught two 2+ pound bass with my Superfine 3wt. Having said that, you can certainly fish big water and catch big fish with a Superfine. The superfine rods are mostly slow with a few medium (full to mid flex), and the Superfine are dedicated to fishing smaller waters for smaller fish. The T3 series are medium to fast rods (mid to tip flex), and they are available in a wide variety of weights for all types of fishing. Superfine (before the ~$80 price increase) with the same deal last fall I chose the BBS to balance with the light rod. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |